Thomas Ptacek, founder of Matasano Security, argues that the most lucrative and rewarding roles in information security are found in application security (appsec), where practitioners focus on attacking software or devising countermeasures for those attacks. Unlike traditional infrastructure roles like firewall deployment, appsec requires a deep understanding of computer science concepts, including compiler theory and microarchitecture.

Programming as a Foundational Requirement

Ptacek emphasizes that the ability to solve problems using programming languages provides a professional with the most control over their career. While many technology professionals prefer to avoid writing software, he suggests that those seeking a career in security must find a way to make programming stick in their minds.

For those specifically interested in application security, the C programming language holds significant cachet, though Java, Python, or Ruby are also viable starting points for learning the fundamentals.

“A lot of very smart technology professionals have concluded that they just don’t enjoy writing software. Those people should reconsider.”

— How to Break Into Security, Ptacek Edition – Krebs on Security

A Technical Roadmap for Practice

To build practical skills, Ptacek suggests a specific workflow: acquire a copy of 'The Web Application Hacker’s Handbook' and use a cloud environment like Amazon EC2 to host ancient versions of WordPress. By deploying these outdated versions, aspiring practitioners can use free tools like OWASP WebScarab or Burp Suite Free Edition to identify and exploit bugs.

For those already in corporate IT roles, the path involves moving toward 'line of business' applications. Ptacek notes that while building these applications may be tedious, defending them can be highly rewarding and provides a significant opportunity to influence a company's security posture.

Trade-offs in Practice Environments

A point of technical debate exists regarding where to host these practice labs. While Ptacek suggests using Amazon EC2 as a 'shooting range' to quickly spin up vulnerable instances, some practitioners argue that local virtual machines (VMs) are superior because they are free, offer full network control, and do not risk violating cloud provider terms of service.

The choice between cloud instances and local VMs involves a trade-off between convenience and isolation. EC2 allows for rapid deployment of specific software versions, while local VMs provide a safer, offline environment that avoids the risk of 'nasty' traffic being flagged by an Internet Service Provider (ISP).

What Hacker News readers are saying

  • Alternative: One commenter suggested that the article requires a significant update to account for the impact of AI on the discipline, arguing that practical realities now allow individuals to be effective by using AI to manage programming and security tasks. comment ↗
  • Skeptical: Several commenters expressed skepticism about the current relevance of the advice, noting that the rapid evolution of technology and the rise of automated agents have fundamentally changed the landscape of application security. comment ↗
  • Skeptical: Another reader argued that the content is so dated that a simple update would be insufficient, suggesting that the industry has changed so much that the original advice is no longer applicable. comment ↗

Summarized opinions from the Hacker News thread, not verified facts. Read the full discussion ↗