The transition from manual mathematical computation to automated engineering tools has fundamentally altered how practitioners interact with the underlying physics of their work. While a 1959 set of notes on mathematics for engineers represents a period of direct calculation, modern engineers often interact with these principles through layers of abstraction provided by CAD software and artificial intelligence.
The Shift Toward Mathematical Abstraction
A Hacker News post shared a 1959 PDF of 'Notes on Mathematics for Engineers,' sparking a discussion on how engineering has evolved over the last 70 years. One commenter, writing as stochastic_tn, expressed a sense of 'grief' over how modern technology has made much of this foundational math knowledge unnecessary for daily practice.
The commenter noted that in many fields, the applied math is now 'baked into' CAD tools. This trend is reportedly extending even into math-heavy sub-disciplines like robotics, where AI tools further automate the processes that previously required manual mathematical oversight.
Proprietary Knowledge and the 'Hoarding' of Math
The discussion highlighted a divide between open academic research and proprietary commercial development. One commenter, upboundspiral, argued that much of the most interesting math is hidden behind 'hyper-proprietary' tools used by major companies.
This includes complex techniques like Finite Element tricks and meshing algorithms. The commenter suggested that while national labs sometimes release reliable open-source work, much of the high-level expertise is often generalized and sold as a closed product, making it difficult for independent researchers to access the core mechanics.
The Role of LLMs and Continuous Approximations
Conversely, some participants argued that modern tools are expanding the scope of what engineers can achieve. One commenter, aatd86, claimed to be using more math than ever since the advent of LLMs, stating that these tools have allowed for more ambitious projects.
The thread also revisited the theoretical value of using continuous math to solve discrete problems. One commenter, oldjohnnylane, shared an anecdote about a mentor who suggested using derivatives to describe CPU cache misses—a discrete event. Others in the thread, including _alternator_, suggested that these continuous approximations can radically simplify complex situations and that LLMs can serve as tutors to help engineers understand these high-level concepts.
Uncertainties in Tool Transparency
While the discussion identifies a trend toward abstraction, the specific extent to which this 'hides' math remains a point of subjective experience. It is unclear how much mathematical proficiency is lost versus how much is simply relocated to the software layer.
Furthermore, the specific 'tricks' and algorithms held by proprietary companies remain largely unknown to the public, leaving a gap between the user's output and the underlying mathematical execution.