Modern heavy artillery can now strike targets at a range of 70 kilometers with an average miss of only two meters, a massive leap from 1940s technology where 16-kilometer shots missed by an average of 50 meters. This shift in precision, combined with the proliferation of ubiquitous sensors, is fundamentally breaking the traditional military doctrine of 'concentration'—the practice of secretly assembling large groups of troops and vehicles to overwhelm an enemy.
The Erosion of Surprise
The synergy of three forces—sensor reach, weapon range, and munition precision—has made the maneuvers of the past nearly impossible to execute. Because radar and acoustic sensors can identify a tank from ten kilometers away, and electronic emissions can locate a soldier making a phone call, the 'secret' assembly of forces is easily compromised.
This creates a growing 'gray zone' where any concentration of vehicles within a few tens of kilometers of the front line is often detected and destroyed within minutes. As these technologies improve, this zone reaches further into what was traditionally considered the safe rear of the battlefield.
“The countryside, traditionally the place where generals like to maneuver, has become extremely dangerous: any concentration of forces is detected and then destroyed from a distance.”
— How should armies fight? - Works in Progress Magazine
Tactical Responses to Surveillance
Militaries currently face three primary options to survive this environment. The first is 'hardening,' where troops disperse and dig deep holes to become less viable targets, though this often results in piecemeal and bloody attacks.
The second option is withdrawing to cities, which provide a 'warren of tunnels' and shelters that preserve mobility. However, relying solely on urban environments can lead to an army being surrounded and cut off from the broader countryside.
A third strategy, advocated by analyst Jack Watling, involves fighting the sensors themselves. This approach uses small, highly mobile groups to target enemy surveillance while deploying their own, supported by heavy artillery from a distance to create a temporary window for movement.
Real-World Application in Ukraine
The conflict in Ukraine serves as a live laboratory for these shifts. Many Ukrainian soldiers now live underground for months at a time, often hundreds of meters from the nearest friendly unit, preferring towns and cities to hold ground.
Conversely, units like the Third Assault Brigade are experimenting with 'sensor-blinding' tactics to move forward. While these attacks appear to be working for now, their long-term viability depends on whether they can successfully keep the enemy's cameras and sensors blinded against ever-improving technology.
What Hacker News readers are saying
- Alternative: One commenter suggested that the current conflict is stuck in a dystopian equilibrium because neither side can achieve large-scale air superiority, potentially shifting the balance only through strikes on strategic infrastructure. comment ↗
- Skeptical: Another reader argued that classical air superiority is becoming obsolete, suggesting that future conflicts will likely devolve into wars of attrition where the side with more finite resources survives. comment ↗
- Experience: One observer noted that modern warfare has been significantly altered by the fact that improvised explosive devices can now be delivered via drones. comment ↗
Summarized opinions from the Hacker News thread, not verified facts. Read the full discussion ↗
